Magicycle Deer Ebike SUV Versus Giant Talon E+ 3

magicycle deer vs giant talon 3

Unless you’ve been camping in the outback for several months, you probably already know that full suspension electric bikes capable of off-road use are the hottest new trend in the world of e-biking.

E-bikes in general, all types, are setting sales records in amazing numbers. Bikes suitable for off-road use in particular are selling like hotcakes.

Electric Wheelers is reader-supported. Although we independently research and test products, we may receive a commission on purchases made from our chosen links. Read more…

What is ESUV Bike?

ESUVs are a very fast-growing segment of the booming e-bike market. There’s no question that off-road biking is an extremely popular activity.

Since March 2022, sales have grown by 60%. Total sales in the US last year reached $1,464,000,000 — and more than 47,000 are being sold every day. Electric sport utility e-bikes (ESUVs) are claiming their share of the bike industry’s growth.

yellow magicycle deer esuv ebike

The extremely fast growth of the electric bike industry has also produced a large number of brands available to consumers.

Road bikes, commuter bikes, electric SUV bikes (ESUVs) – people everywhere are learning about the many pluses that come with healthy and fun outdoor exercise.

That health benefit can easily be combined with real savings in the cost of commuting. This is true for those who commute to their workplace daily, and also for anyone who makes regular trips to the grocery store, post office, gym, etc.

How to Choose an Electric SUV Bike?

In selecting an ESUV, it is very important to choose a brand that owns the factory that builds its e-bikes.

After all, if the brand does not own a factory, how can it possibly maintain full quality control?

Let’s take a look at two bikes with off-road capability, both manufactured by brands that do own the factory that builds their e-bikes – the Magicycle Deer and the Giant Talon E+ 3. Congratulations to both these brands for manufacturing their own bikes!

The Measure of a Comfortable ESUV

If you’re willing to invest in purchasing an ESUV bike, it’s almost certain that you plan to spend a lot of time riding. It could be that you are an avid explorer — you love the backwoods trails and offroad adventures.

You’re at your best when you’re leaving behind the noise of heavy traffic and the smell of exhaust fumes.

Sometimes you just need to “get away from it all” and enjoy a little quietness and scenic beauty. A good ESUV bike can be just what you need.

Read also: Magicycle Deer Full Review

There are endless possibilities, maybe just you alone, or maybe you and a friend or your entire family.

And a good ESUV can also double as a daily commuter, and of course, it’s a great machine for running errands to the grocery store or post office. Whatever type of riding you do, when spending a lot of time in the saddle you want a comfortable ride.

ESUV Suspension

The major factor on any electric sport utility bike is suspension when you’re thinking about comfort.

ESUVs can make your dream of forest pathways, bubbling streams, and gorgeous mountain vistas. Getting to all these wonderful places will also involve unexpected protruding tree roots, chunks of rock, dropoffs, washboarded gravel roads, and potholes that will jar your teeth.

rear suspension of magicycle deer

Even if most of your ESUV riding is on pavement, every rider manages to find more than his share of bumps. That’s why suspension is so important for comfort.

There’s no question about it. Full suspension is the choice of most ESUV riders.

Also known as softail, full suspension bikes are much less susceptible to those jarring bumps and dips.

A full suspension ESUV has the usual front fork suspension for the front wheel, but it also has special suspension to help absorb the unpleasant energy that can be transferred through the rear wheel to your back and neck.

It’s not only much more comfortable, but it’s also safer riding, providing you with better control.

The Magicycle Deer ESUV is a full suspension ride, providing the comfort factor that only a softail can offer.

The Giant Talon E+ 3 is what is commonly known as a hardtail. It has only the front fork suspension, with no suspension for the rear wheel.

Fat Tires

 You don’t need to be a genius to understand that a 4″ wide tire contributes to the stability of how an ESUV rides. A fat tire has a lot of surface area contacting the road, so naturally, traction is dramatically increased.

That 4″ wide fat tire also provides a more stable and secure ride. And then the fat tire opens up a truly diverse option for terrain choices: sand, gravel, mud, snow, forest pathways, and rocky trails. All are much more rideable with fat tires.

Fat tire bikes have been around much longer than most people would guess. There are historical indications of fat tire bikes in the early 1900s, and we know that serious experimentation happened no later than about 1988.

Simultaneously, in two widely separated US states, genuine interest in fat tires was developing at about the same time.

The Magicycle Deer full suspension ESUV is nicely adorned with 26″ X 4″ Kenda fat tires. The tires are comfortable and stable.

The Talon E+ 3 has tires that are 2.4″ wide — nowhere near the surface area of the Magicycle Deer tires.

The Measure of a Powerful ESUV

Sure, every ESUV rider wants a comfortable bike and the most stable tires, but none of that is enjoyable unless you also have power and plenty of it!

When you think about quick starts, cruising speed, and hill-climbing ability — all these are dependent on power.

You want a softail ESUV equipped with a strong motor, providing plenty of power. Those steep climbs where you catch the best views are no fun at all without a powerful high-torque motor.

The Magicycle Deer comes equipped with a 750-watt (1100 peak watts) motor that will satisfy the demands of hill climbing, regardless of whether you ride in downtown San Francisco or the Rocky Mountain National Park.

man riding with yellow Magicycle deer

For easy, comfortable, relaxed riding, this mighty hub motor is an obvious choice. That choice is confirmed when you realize that hub motors are far more economical than mid-drive motors.

With 1100 watts of peak power, the Magicycle Deer’s hub motor is the perfect size. If you settle for a 500-watt motor, your ESUV will feel underpowered on the steep hills.

What about the Giant Talon E+ 3? This hardtail is equipped with a 250-watt mid-drive motor. That’s right…only 250 watts.

Hub Motor vs Mid-Drive Motor

The design of mid-drive motors requires a much larger number of moving parts. This naturally means more wear and tear, along with a greater possibility of motor failure.

Mid-drive motors are also more complex to install or replace, which adds to the expense.

Even if you are new to e-biking, with a hub motor you can be very quickly riding with confidence. For example, shifting is often unnecessary if your bike is powered by a hub motor, and you can even shift when the bike is stopped.

But with a mid-drive motor, the bike must be moving before the rider can shift, and while riding, it must be shifted frequently.

The Magicycle Deer’s motor delivers a huge 96 Newton meters of torque.

It’s not necessary to understand how torque is measured. Just be aware that the Deer’s torque is about the same as many 800 cc motorcycles.

With a Magicycle Deer full suspension ESUV, there’s a great combination of comfort and power.

The Measure of ESUV Electrical Energy

It’s great to have a strong high-torque motor, but that doesn’t help much unless you also have a powerful battery.

You might think the MAGiCYCLE Design Team would simply carry over the fabulous 52-volt battery from the original cruisers.

No–instead of taking the cheap and easy route, they have opted to give the softail Magicycle Deer a freshly designed battery.

This remarkable battery is designed to give riders even more range. Even though the amp hour rating has been increased from 15 to 20, this bigger and more powerful new battery is still beautifully integrated into the frame…even more than previous Magicycle models.

This battery provides Magicycle Deer owners a 25% boost in amps, meaning you can look forward to long rides without worrying about battery life.

Of course, if you tip the scales at 290 pounds and ride mostly in hilly terrain, that will reduce your range. The range will also vary according to wind speed, tire pressure, and your pedaling habits.

The Giant Talon E+ 3 is equipped with a 36-volt 11-amp hour battery. Shoppers will want to note that this Talon’s battery is capable of only 396 watt-hours as compared to a whopping 1040 watt-hours from the Magicycle Deer’s battery.

How Much is the Magicycle Deer?

Magicycle Deer is now available at only $2,699. Also, Magicycle has another surprise for its customers. Throughout February, you could have $300 off by using the coupon code FH300.

Limited offer, come check it out.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top